What is the better style of Aikido for self defence: Aikikai or Yoshinkan?

August 22, 2010


What is the better style of Aikido for self defence: Aikikai or Yoshinkan?

Answers in Comments below..


Click to go to site..

Comments

6 Responses to “What is the better style of Aikido for self defence: Aikikai or Yoshinkan?”

  1. joe_kemjiu on August 22nd, 2010 11:00 am

    Both styles are good, they came from one root and with similar objective, to defend oneself or others from physical threat.

    Better visit them and observe, ask necessary questions that can accommodate your concern.

    Good luck

  2. Kendall Sylvan on August 22nd, 2010 11:00 am

    this is going to be true for any martial art… Its effectiveness first depends on your instructor and what you were taught. Then you have to be able to practice and properly execute the techniques that you learned. Most styles can be very useful and help a person that studies and puts time into them, but bad instruction takes a lot away from what you learn.

  3. Shienaran on August 22nd, 2010 11:00 am

    Either one will do fine, you just need to find a good instructor.

  4. Shiro Kuma on August 22nd, 2010 11:00 am

    It depends on the particular instructor, and his/her ability to teach beyond the confines of formal aikido kata. I’ve trained with and under a lot of great aikido instructors from both affiliations.

    Also, please remember that Aikikai is the name of an organization, that includes a lot of different styles. For instance, the late Shoji Nishio-sensei’s version of Aikido is often considered the most unique, but he is still part of the Aikikai.

  5. MMA on August 22nd, 2010 11:00 am

    I do not believe that either are very sufficient for street self defense, but maybe Yoshinkan?

  6. Chil-Hyun Ahn on August 22nd, 2010 11:00 am

    Yoshinkan because it emphasizes self defense applications and places particularly heavy emphasis on proper stances and basic movements. Practicing this will help one to understand how to move their kamae around to put themselves in a better stances.

Got something to say?








Powered by Yahoo! Answers